A two page thread at Cre8asite Forums named What do you learn from Matt Cutts?, Does he give you SEO advices?... He basically asks, is Matt's blog an SEO blog that SEOs can learn from?
Member Nadir gives Matt a really hard time. Saying that "his blog looks just like sensational newspapers." He compares some of the entries, where he calls out spammers, the same thing to witch trials done "middle ages, witches were executed in public in Europe."
There are some in the thread that agree with Nadir and some that do not.
Ruud offers up a post with many reason why Matt's blog is very important to SEOs. Concluding that "every Google employee should have a blog and post as much as possible about what keeps them busy. Just keep on talking."
This is all in response to Matt Winning Best SEO Blog at SEJ.
Forum discussion at Cre8asite Forums.